here's a short list of teams and how they did with a rookie catcher:

User account number (uid): 46
Posted by nuschler on 2010-01-24 19:44:36
In Reply to: I'm sure there is benefit to having a catcher out there who knows the hitters. posted by shikantaza on 2010-01-24 18:47:31

1968 cincinnati reds -4 games.

1947 yankees +10 games.

1901 orioles were 48-89 with a rookie catcher (the first year in league for the team).

1948 dodgers -10 games.

1975 expos -4 games.

1925 A's +17 games.

1929 yankees -13 games.

1929 browns -3 games.

1972 red sox had a better winning percentage than the '71 sox with a rookie.

the '23 cubs +3 games.

'32 reds +2 games.

1913 white sox were even.

'91 rangers -2 games.

'70 yankees +13 games.

'73 phillies +12 games.

'70 cardinals -11 games.

'98 red sox +16 games.

'55 yankees -7 games.

'93 dodgers +18 games.

'73 brewers +9 games.

'78 detroit +12 games.

'97 yankees +4 games.

'61 braves -5 games.

Thread:

Peterson: Sabean playing with fire - nuschler 2010-01-23 11:03:15 (359 views)
- btw... MLOLina - shikantaza 2010-01-24 17:31:27 (174 views)
  - Well, since he's a Giant again, - Hawk_941 2010-01-24 23:45:14 (176 views)
  - molina caught 12 shutouts last season1! - nuschler 2010-01-24 17:57:23 (118 views)
- I wonder if the team would have been better with no FSanchez or Molina - shikantaza 2010-01-23 11:11:22 (223 views)
  - i tend to agree - wiz 2010-01-24 15:54:49 (147 views)
    - "I don't know," he said. "It feels the same coming out, it's just not reading on the radar gun." - wiz 2010-01-24 16:13:23 (170 views)
      - This quote kind of flies in the face of what Krukow said on the broadcast - Hawk_941 2010-01-24 23:38:55 (139 views)
  - no I don't think so...Bumgarner is going to be fine - The Dude 2010-01-24 12:05:07 (163 views)
    - MadBum will be fine, but people act like Posey would have thrown to third - shikantaza 2010-01-24 12:34:48 (207 views)
      - catchers call their own games in the Majors... - The Dude 2010-01-24 15:15:58 (154 views)
        
        yes, I'm sure that Posey will keep demanding a fastball down the middle in an 0-2 count - shikantaza 2010-01-24 17:15:11 (153 views)
        
        no...wouldn't do that.....but he doesn't know the hitters as well as Molina does - The Dude 2010-01-24 18:37:11 (147 views)
        
        I'm sure there is benefit to having a catcher out there who knows the hitters. - shikantaza 2010-01-24 18:47:31 (148 views)
        
        here's a short list of teams and how they did with a rookie catcher: - nuschler 2010-01-24 19:44:36 (165 views)
        
        hmmm... doesn't seem to indicate some significant detriment - shikantaza 2010-01-25 10:28:10 (122 views)
        
        i didn't check to see how much experience those catchers had at the position - nuschler 2010-01-25 12:27:18 (130 views)
        
        that's true... let's hope they're right. - shikantaza 2010-01-25 15:50:00 (119 views)
        
        maybe they should consider Madbum's arbitration elgibility as well - LG 2010-01-25 15:08:59 (138 views)
        
        i'm sure they are. - nuschler 2010-01-25 15:27:16 (108 views)
      - The Giants asked Bumgarner to reduce the velocity of his fastball - Hawk_941 2010-01-24 13:41:51 (178 views)
        
        sure... but if that's a new technique for him, it's all the more reason - shikantaza 2010-01-24 13:57:45 (150 views)
        
        Who gives a shit about velocity, as long as he gets outs - Duck the Fodgers 2010-01-24 22:03:10 (139 views)
        
        Seriously? I mean, I agree. I'd love to have Greg Maddux, but in terms of projection for a minor - shikantaza 2010-01-25 15:48:49 (141 views)
  - posey isnt ready to call a mlb game, he needs more minor league innings - FaTaL Dizzle 2010-01-23 23:40:12 (222 views)
    - MadBum doesn't need more innings? - shikantaza 2010-01-24 00:34:24 (181 views)
  - It's definitely a possibility. Maybe a higher ceiling, but - Hawk_941 2010-01-23 13:36:22 (205 views)

You must be registered and logged in to post. Please select an option:

Login with existing account
Create a new account


	Login Name: Login Name is required Password: Password is required Invalid Credentials This account is not yet activated Please check your email and follow the instructions


	Login Name: Login Name is required Another account is already using that login name Email Address: Email Address is required Another account is already using that email address Password: Password is required Re-Enter Password: Password is required Passwords don't match Please fill out the reCAPTCHA field The reCAPTCHA entered did not match the image