it was a blanket finish between timmy, wainwright, and carpenter. carpenter had the best w-L pct, era, and whip (barely). wainwright had the most wins, and innings pitched, and timmy had the most strike outs. the two cardinal pitchers seemed to cancel each other out, and timmy sort of backed in. i would have given it to carpenter myself, but who cares? all i know is that my favorite player of all time, juan marichal, never won one, so it means nothing to me...