I'd give it to Posey... doing all that while playing catcher makes him extremely valuable

User account number (uid): 79
Posted by shikantaza on 2010-08-23 23:08:53
In Reply to: If Strasburg's done for the year, does that make Posey or Garcia the favorite to win ROY? posted by The Lucky Cap on 2010-08-23 22:27:33

Jay hasn't even got that much better of a line at this point and has 100 fewer ABs. Garcia is awesome, but he's only #6 in the NL in ERA and his peripheral stats seem to indicate that he is overachieving. If you go based off of hitters with 300 plate appearances, Posey is second in the NL in hitting, plus he's holding his own playing the most important defensive position in the game.

Give it to Posey.

Thread:

If Strasburg's done for the year, does that make Posey or Garcia the favorite to win ROY? - The Lucky Cap 2010-08-23 22:27:33 (82 views)
- may come down to whether STL or SF goes to the Playoffs.. - Ghost Dog 2010-08-24 18:36:15 (38 views)
  - very good point! - The Lucky Cap 2010-08-24 19:55:33 (36 views)
- Re: If Strasburg's done for the year, does that make Posey or Garcia the favorite to win ROY? - skontch 2010-08-24 13:11:54 (56 views)
  - The East Coast bias often plays into these things, unfortunately. - Hawk_941 2010-08-24 15:27:52 (30 views)
    - +1 although it has more to do w/ exposure and the fact that West Coast games play - JoeDaddy 2010-08-24 16:27:55 (39 views)
- I'd give it to Posey... doing all that while playing catcher makes him extremely valuable - shikantaza 2010-08-23 23:08:53 (66 views)
  - I'd give it to Posey, too. - Hawk_941 2010-08-24 10:04:30 (54 views)
    - I don't know that anyone here would give it to anyone other than Posey ... - The Lucky Cap 2010-08-24 11:42:18 (49 views)
      - Heyward has the buzz to go with his good all-around game. - Hawk_941 2010-08-24 12:31:33 (34 views)

You must be registered and logged in to post. Please select an option:

Login with existing account
Create a new account


	Login Name: Login Name is required Password: Password is required Invalid Credentials This account is not yet activated Please check your email and follow the instructions


	Login Name: Login Name is required Another account is already using that login name Email Address: Email Address is required Another account is already using that email address Password: Password is required Re-Enter Password: Password is required Passwords don't match Please fill out the reCAPTCHA field The reCAPTCHA entered did not match the image